A cannibalistic nightmare: the terrifying ordeal of the Donner Party

In 1846, a group of families left the American Midwest in search of a new life in California – but one disastrous shortcut left them fighting for their lives. Jonny Wilkes tells the harrowing story of the Donner Party

Black-and-white historical engraving of distressed men, women, and children gathered outside makeshift tents in a barren landscape

Published: November 22, 2026 at 3:30 PM

Save

The 19th century brought monumental change to the landscape of the United States. As the still-fledgling nation acquired more territory, more American eyes began to look out across the vast continent and envisage a better life in the west. The Oregon Territory and California, then part of Mexico, promised prosperity, freedom and a fresh start, inspiring pioneering migrants to brave the difficult and dangerous journey to carve out their own slice of paradise there.

Ad

Driving this westward expansion was ‘manifest destiny’ – the belief that it was the God-given right and duty of the US to extend its borders to the Pacific Ocean and beyond. That phrase first appeared in 1845; the very next year, a group of would-be settlers set out along the recently established Oregon Trail to realise that dream. Instead, they endured a nightmare, created from a catalogue of errors and misfortunes. Their name evokes a macabre chapter in US history: the Donner Party.

The Reeds and the Donners

The doomed party began with two large families from Illinois who joined the wave of humanity to California. There were the Reeds, headed by Irish-born businessman James Reed, and the Donners, led by farming brothers George and Jacob Donner. Accompanying them were their wives, children, servants and teamsters to drive the wagons, as well as cattle and horses.

In an intriguing ‘what-if’, a bright young lawyer by the name of Abraham Lincoln seriously considered going too. The future president, a friend of Reed’s, was talked out of it by his wife Mary Todd, and turned his attentions to his political career instead.

On 14 April 1846, the Reeds and Donners set out from Springfield, Illinois, bound for Independence, Missouri, the starting point of the great trails to the west. The town provided them with the opportunity to stock up and attach themselves to a wagon train for the 2,000-plus-mile journey, which usually took four to six months.

Black-and-white 19th-century studio portrait of James and Margaret Reed seated side by side in formal Victorian attire

James Reed with his wife, Margaret. The couple were leading members of the Donner Party – but James would later be banished from the group

When they left Independence on 12 May, it was already late in the migration season: it was important to go late enough to avoid the rains and mud of spring, while ensuring plenty of grass for the cattle, but early enough to beat the snow.

Aware of the time pressure, they covered the ground to Fort Laramie (now in Wyoming) by late June with little incident, except for the death of Reed’s elderly and sickly mother-in-law, Sarah Keyes. From there, migrants tended to turn north to Fort Hall either to carry on with the Oregon Trail or join the California Trail. Most of the wagon train kept to the established track.

George Donner, however, took the lead of a breakaway group, which included the Reeds as well as the Breen, Eddy, Murphy, McCutchen and Keseberg families, and later the Graves family too. The so-called Donner Party numbered 87 people, nearly half of whom were children.

The shortcut

The party decided to take a new route, known as the Hastings Cutoff. An explorer named Lansford Hastings had written a book, The Emigrants’ Guide to Oregon and California, in which he promoted a shortcut he had devised. Instead of going north and around the Great Salt Lake, he suggested trekking over the Wasatch Mountains and straight across the Great Salt Lake Desert, apparently saving more than 350 miles.

In reality, the Hastings Cutoff added around 125 miles and Hastings had never traversed the route in its entirety, let alone gauged its suitability for wagons and cattle. Yet he sent out letters offering to guide migrants, which is how he enticed members of the Donner Party.

Reed even ignored warnings by an old friend not to trust Hastings, while another traveller, journalist Edwin Bryant, wrote his own letters warning against the use of the shortcut, but these went undelivered. The proprietor of a trading post – who stood to profit from use of the Hastings Cutoff – managed to hide the letters, and instead told the party to expect a smooth road.

Illustrated map of the western United States tracing the routes of the Oregon Trail, California Trail, and Hastings Cutoff from Independence, Missouri to Oregon City and Sutter's Fort

A map showing the Oregon and California Trails. The Donner Party followed the Oregon Trail west from Independence, Missouri, before opting to take the Hastings Cutoff – a decision that had disastrous consequences | Credit: Jared Manninen

What they found was nearly impassable terrain and no Hastings to help them. He had gone ahead to guide another group, so the Donner Party relied on instructions left along the way. They forged a path through the wilderness, clearing the brush, stones and trees, and dragged their wagons up the steep mountains. At their slowest, they progressed just 1.5 miles a day, causing them to fall behind schedule.

Banished from the party

When the party reached the Great Salt Lake Desert, an arid expanse of salt flats without water or grass, they found a note from Hastings claiming it would take two days to cross. In the end, it took five, with the days baking hot, the nights painfully cold, and every step hindered as the wagons sank in the sticky crust of the desert. Supplies ran low, wagons had to be abandoned, many cattle died or fled, and everyone was exhausted by the time they reached the other side.

They did not get to the Humboldt River, where they reconnected with the well-trodden trail to California, until late September. The Hastings Cutoff delayed them by a month and so raised serious doubts over whether they could cross the Sierra Nevada mountains before the snows fell. Morale, energy and supplies plummeted, and cattle numbers dwindled in raids from local Native American tribes. Four deaths came in quick succession, including an old man left on the road when he could go no further.

Painting of a pioneer wagon train pulled by oxen and followed by pack mules crossing a vast, barren desert plain toward distant mountains

A painting depicts a wagon train crossing the Great Salt Lake Desert towards California. The Donner Party crossed the same unforgiving terrain, losing many of their cattle and using up most of their supplies in the process | Credit: California Trail Interpretive Center

Then, on 5 October, Reed got into a fight and killed a teamster called John Snyder. Wagon trains administered their own justice and, against calls for his hanging, Reed was banished from the party, with his family permitted to stay. This could have been a death sentence, but, as it turned out, this decision ultimately saved his life and the lives of others. The Donners, meanwhile, fell behind when a wagon was damaged and George severely cut his hand during the repairs.

There was a brief glimmer of optimism when Charles Stanton, who had gone ahead in search of supplies, returned with food and two Miwok guides, known by the westernised names Luis and Salvador. All hopes of completing the journey that season were finally dashed, however, when they reached a pass high up in the mountains already blocked by snow. The Donner Party had no choice but to see out the winter as best they could.

Murder for meat

The majority set up a rudimentary camp at Truckee Lake, sheltering in a few dilapidated cabins built by previous travellers, as well as tents and lean-tos. The Donner families and a handful of others had to make do with even more ramshackle shelter several miles back near Alder Creek. There they remained for months as the winter weather intensified. A blizzard lasting more than a week blanketed the area in deep snow, all but burying the camps and killing off the remaining cattle.

Food supplies soon ran out, and the only meat left was the occasional mouse found in the cabins. Facing starvation – unless the cold killed them first – people boiled the oxhides used for shelter and sucked out the jelly they produced, or gnawed at tree bark. The last animal bones were boiled for broth so many times that they crumbled in the mouth. Baylis Williams, one of the Reeds’ workers, was the first to die of malnutrition; others soon followed.

By December, the situation had become so desperate that a small group from Truckee Lake set out on a highly dangerous attempt to cross the mountain pass in makeshift snowshoes and get help. The group started with 17 of the healthiest members, including a couple of children, but two turned back quickly. The others trudged on with minimal equipment and food, and with diminishing strength. Later historians dubbed them ‘the Forlorn Hope’.

Coloured 19th-century engraving of exhausted pioneers huddled inside and beside a makeshift tent during a driving snowstorm in a pine forest

An engraving depicts members of the Donner Party huddling together for warmth during the winter of 1846–47. Trapped by heavy snow and desperately short of food, several of the pioneers died of starvation | Credit: Alamy

After a week that brought them to the brink of death, the group were forced to contemplate the ultimate taboo of survival: cannibalism. Although many were intensely reluctant – even when the first deaths occurred, the bodies were not touched – there soon remained no other choice.

Patrick Dolan, the first to suggest eating human flesh, lost his mind with hypothermia, stripped off his clothes and ran into the trees, dying just a few hours later. The group gave in and cannibalised his body. Soon, the remains of everyone who perished were also cut up and stored for food. Care was taken to ensure that no one ate the flesh of a relative.

When that still proved insufficient, though, talk turned to killing the guides, Luis and Salvador. While they initially escaped, the others caught up with them a few days later and a man named William Foster shot them. This is the only instance in the Donner Party of murder committed for meat, and serves as a damning demonstration of how little the lives of Native Americans were regarded.

Eight of the Forlorn Hope would die before the survivors wandered into a Miwok camp after 33 days. They would not have made it without resorting to cannibalism.

The relief parties

After arriving at the Miwok camp, the group raised the alarm. Leaving Sutter’s Fort in early 1847 and trekking into the snowy mountains, a relief party managed to reach Truckee Lake in mid-February, but saw no signs of life. Only when they called out did a woman, Levinah Murphy, poke her head out of the snow and, on seeing the newcomers, remark, “Are you men from California, or do you come from heaven?”

High-angle view of Donner Lake nestled among dense evergreen forests and distant mountains, framed by rugged granite cliffs in the foreground.

The Donner Party split into two camps, one of which was based on the edge of Truckee Lake in California’s Sierra Nevada. The lake was later renamed Donner Lake after the group | Credit: Getty Images

The state of the buried camp was horrendous, with 13 dead and the rest emaciated and mentally frail. The situation at Alder Creek was no better. While the rescuers knew they could not take everyone with them, especially the weak and infirm, they led 23 of the Donner Party back down the mountains, nearly all children. During the arduous journey, two died, and another died once they reached safety.

On the way, though, they passed another relief party. At the front was none other than James Reed. Having reached California following his banishment, he had grown increasingly worried when the others, including his family, did not appear, and worked tirelessly to organise a rescue effort. He discovered his wife and children all alive.

In fact, no one else had died at the camps, but cannibalism had become widespread. The rescuers saw a man named Jean Baptiste Trudeau carrying a human leg, and the organs of Jacob Donner being used to sustain his own children.

The second relief took another 17 away, mostly children from the Breen and Graves families, leaving just five each at Truckee Lake and Alder Creek. The return journey was miserable, with three deaths and the rest growing so weak that their rescuers left them. They only survived what became known as ‘Starved Camp’ through cannibalism.

Even the arrival of a third relief effort did not bring salvation as there were not enough men to carry all the children. That was until a man named John Stark refused to leave them, and began carrying each child a little distance at a time before returning for another and repeating the process.

Black-and-white historical illustration of a small group of travelers trekking across a deep snowfield in a pine-lined mountain valley past buried cabins with smoking chimneys

Rescuers approach one of the Donner Party’s encampments. Several relief parties eventually reached the stranded travellers – but dozens died before the ordeal was over | Credit: Getty Images

While Stark heroically brought nine children down the mountain, other members of the third relief carried on to the camps, including Forlorn Hope members William Foster and William Eddy. They learned that, in their absence, their children had perished, and one of the survivors, Lewis Keseberg, admitted to eating Eddy’s son.

With the rescuers saving another five children, only a handful remained. Keseberg refused to leave, Levinah Murphy was too weak, George Donner was unable to move due to the hand injury he sustained months earlier (which had turned gangrenous), and George’s wife Tamsen chose to stay with him, knowing this likely guaranteed her death.

Heroes and villains

It would be weeks before one last party set out for the camps in April 1847 – not with the expectation of finding anyone else alive, but to retrieve belongings. Yet at the Truckee Lake camp was a sole survivor, Keseberg. Before he was brought away, though, it was said that he acted suspiciously and was found with a cooking pot filled with human flesh and some of the Donners’ possessions. Unproven claims that he murdered Tamsen emerged, and sensationalised stories in the newspapers made him something of a villain – a reputation that haunted Keseberg for the rest of his life.

Of the 87 members of the Donner Party who went into the mountains in the winter of 1846, 48 came out the other side, and of the individual families, only the Reeds and Breens did not suffer a death. Everyone who lived, however, carried with them the trauma of their ordeal and the measures they took to survive. Virginia Reed wrote to a cousin back east, saying, “I have not wrote you half of the truble, but I hav Wrote you anuf to let you now what truble is.”

Black-and-white historical photograph of a large wooden memorial cross with a ladder leaning against it, standing in a snowy mountain valley overlooking a frozen lake

A cross has stood at the site of the Donner Lake cabins since 1887, commemorating those who died during the expedition | Credit: California State Library

But as they looked to build their lives in California, the tragedy of the Donner Party was already entering American folklore. Truckee Lake and the trail became known as Donner Lake and Donner Pass respectively, and the site of the cabins was turned into a tourist attraction as early as the 1850s. A plethora of accounts and books also emerged, framing the story in terms of heroes like Tamsen Donner and villains like Keseberg.

Ad

In the end, it proved ineffective as a cautionary tale of the dangers of westward expansion and did little to stem the flow of migrants, especially after the discovery of gold in California. Virginia Reed herself did not want her “truble” to dishearten future pioneers; as she made clear in her letter, the pain the Donner Party endured began with one costly mistake: “Never take no cutofs and hury along as fast as you can.”

Authors

Jonny WilkesFreelance writer

Jonny Wilkes is a former staff writer for BBC History Revealed, and he continues to write for both the magazine and HistoryExtra. He has BA in History from the University of York.

Ad

Ad

Loading...

Ad

Loading...