I visited one of America’s “most haunted” historical sites. What I found there astonished me

The rise of ‘dark tourism’ in the US South is decried by some as unethical and exploitative. But as Caitlin Blackwell Baines discovers on a visit to a reputedly haunted plantation mansion, it can also encourage us to engage with the shameful history of slavery

A large historic plantation-style house sits among tall oak trees draped with Spanish moss. The house has a wide front porch with ornate wrought‑iron railings, green shutters, and several dormer windows on the roof. A garden pathway leads to the front steps, bordered by manicured plants and shaded by the surrounding trees.

Published: August 9, 2026 at 3:30 PM

Save

In August 2024, my husband and I embarked on an eccentric adventure: a week-long, 1,500-mile road trip through the American South, visiting supposedly haunted landmarks along the way. The primary impetus for this eerie excursion was to experience in person some of the properties that would feature in my book How to Build a Haunted House (Profile Books, 2025).

Ad

To be clear, I wasn’t on the hunt for ghosts per se. Rather, I was in search of an explanation for why certain historic houses develop the reputation for being haunted – and why we can’t seem to get enough of them. I knew that in the US – below the Mason-Dixon Line demarking the former divide between free North and enslaving South, especially – there were numerous examples.

It was this quest that brought my husband and me to the small town of St Francisville, Louisiana for a night’s stay at the notoriously haunted Myrtles Plantation. What we found there astonished us.

Spiritual awakening

Standing in a fertile upland region flanking the Mississippi River, Myrtles Plantation is 30 miles north of the state capital, Baton Rouge, and some 100 miles from the region’s cultural capital, New Orleans.

Constructed in 1796 for General David Bradford, the 22-room mansion once sat at the centre of a thriving 1,600-hectare (4,000-acre) cotton and indigo plantation. Before the abolition of slavery in the US in 1865, the plantation’s extensive fields were worked by as many as 500 enslaved Black labourers.

Over a century and a half, the property was occupied by a succession of owners, most of whom enjoyed a luxurious lifestyle financed by the cotton industry. Since at least the 1950s, though, the house and grounds have been open to the public – and the mansion earned a reputation as one of the most haunted homes in America.

A black‑and‑white photograph shows a group of men, women, and a child walking along a dirt path beside a field. Each person carries a large sack or bundle—likely cotton—balanced on their head or shoulders. They move in a line through a rural landscape with open fields and distant trees, suggesting agricultural labour in a past era.

Cotton pickers at work on the Alexander Knox Plantation in Mount Pleasant, South Carolina, c1865. The cotton industry was very lucrative and multiple owners of the Myrtles Plantation also benefited from the trade | Credit: Getty Images

The earliest recorded references to spiritual presences at the plantation date to the 1940s, in publications such as Louisiana: A Guide to the State (1941) and Ghosts Along the Mississippi (1948). Notably, these early accounts mention only one resident spectre: an unknown white woman described as “a little old French lady in a green bonnet”.

Over the ensuing decades, however, the Myrtles’ ghost population would not only grow but diversify. By the early 1980s, at least five spirits had been reported: an enslaved female, a Union soldier, a pair of adolescent smallpox victims and a murdered estate manager – William Drew Winter, the only apparition with a firm identity, who was shot by an unknown assailant on the front porch in 1871. At present, there are said to be no fewer than 12 supernatural entities active on the property – the most famous of whom is known as Chloe.

As the story goes, Chloe was a beautiful young enslaved woman who got caught eavesdropping through the keyhole of her master’s office. As punishment, he lopped off her left ear and banished her from the mansion to toil in the blistering heat of the nearby cookhouse.

In revenge – or, in some versions of the story, a misguided attempt to get invited back into the mansion to care for the family – Chloe baked a poison-laced birthday cake, which killed the master’s wife and two of his children. The penalty was death: she was hanged from the bough of a live oak tree on the front lawn. Unsurprisingly, her ghost is said to have haunted the plantation ever since.

As punishment, he lopped off her left ear and banished her from the mansion to toil in the blistering heat of the nearby cookhouse

Today, Chloe is the star attraction at the Myrtles. Indeed, a large black-and-white photo purportedly capturing her ghostly silhouette greets visitors at the main entrance to the mansion. Aside from that grainy image, though, there is very little evidence to support her existence – living or dead. Like so many other legends attached to haunted houses, the historical record suggests that her story is, in fact, a synthesis of real and imagined individuals and events that have coalesced over time to create a compelling narrative.

Ominous omens

I can’t say that I feared encountering the infamous Chloe during our stay at the Myrtles, but I was slightly apprehensive about the visit. It probably didn’t help that our first introduction to Louisiana bore all the hallmarks of a horror film.

On the last leg of our days’ long drive through the heart of the South, just as we passed over the Mississippi-Louisiana border, the hazy late-summer sky suddenly blackened. In an instant the heavens opened, unleashing a deluge so heavy that it nearly obscured our vision through the windscreen. Thunder rumbled; fork-lightning cracked.

It was an appropriately ominous start to a night spent at a haunted house. By the time we finally pulled up to the plantation gates and made our way down the oak-lined drive, though, the rain had subsided. And here we were more than a little surprised to find that the property didn’t quite live up to the stereotypical haunted house of our imagination.

Thunder rumbled; fork-lightning cracked. It was an appropriately ominous start to a night spent at a haunted house

Rather than a derelict old wreck, the Myrtles Plantation is a bustling tourist enterprise. We arrived on a Friday night, and the place was teeming with visitors. Some had come for a celebratory meal at Restaurant 1796, the plantation’s high-end eatery, others for a tour. A few, including my husband and me, had booked a night’s stay in the boutique bed and breakfast.

The main house, where we would be staying, was not nearly as imposing as I had expected. A relatively compact one-and-a-half-storey clapboard structure with seafoam-green shutters and delicate ironwork railings, it appeared less haunted mansion and more quaint country cottage.

Alongside the house stood a noticeably older, more rustic building. Once the original farmstead, it has been converted into a brightly lit cafe and gift shop. Nearby, a centuries-old carriage house has been similarly retrofitted into a funky modern eatery.

Beyond that stretches landscaped parkland, whimsically illuminated by twinkling fairy lights strung from the branches of the plantation’s signature crepe myrtles. The excited shrieks and peals of laughter of guests on one of the evening’s two scheduled ghost tours reached us through the still night air.

A black‑and‑white photograph shows a group of adults and children gathered in front of a wooden building with horizontal planks. Some sit on the ground while others stand or sit on benches. They wear 19th‑century clothing, including long dresses, headscarves, shirts, and hats. The group is arranged closely together on a dirt patch outdoors, suggesting a moment of daily life captured in a rural setting.

A large group of ‘contrabands’ – formerly enslaved people who escaped slavery during the civil war – sit outside Foller’s House, Virginia, 1862. The torture of enslaved people has been turned into a commodity, creating tourist attractions rooted in suffering | Credit: Getty Images

It was an oddly incongruous scene at a property steeped in a very dark history. Its very existence was the direct result of the institution of slavery. What’s more, as a heritage attraction, its main claim to fame was being haunted by tortured enslaved people, murder victims and assorted other casualties of disease and war.

Yet, far from a sombre setting, the atmosphere at the Myrtles was almost jubilant. It welcomed a throng of happy holidaymakers enjoying decadent Southern cuisine, playful ghost stories and plush accommodation.

Allure of the eerie

How did this former enslaver’s home come to be transformed into a multi-million-dollar leisure business attracting some 60,000 visitors annually? It seems a strange turn of events for a historical setting seemingly mired in misery. Yet the Myrtles Plantation is by no means an anomaly. It’s just one of hundreds of heritage sites across the American South capitalising on the rise of so-called ‘dark tourism’.

Simply put, dark tourism is the recreational practice of visiting sites associated with death and suffering – places such as historic crime scenes, battlefields, prisons, sanitoriums and cemeteries. Such sites can be found across the globe and, to some extent, have always drawn the morbidly curious: consider, for example, the ancient Roman Colosseum or the Tyburn Gallows in the 18th century. But over the past few decades, dark tourism has experienced a notable boom in the Southern states.

A colour photograph of the interior of the Colosseum in Rome, showing its tall stone walls, stacked arches, and tiered seating. The centre of the arena is open to reveal the hypogeum—rectangular chambers and passageways where underground structures once stood. Sunlight falls across the worn stone, highlighting the scale and age of the ancient amphitheatre.

Dark tourism has generated interest in many sites associated with suffering, including the Colosseum in Rome (pictured) and more recently, American slave plantations | Credit: Getty Images

In dark tourism epicentres such as New Orleans and Savannah, Georgia, visitors looking for a scare are spoiled for choice, with literally dozens of tour companies catering to their needs. In these settings, the most popular form of dark recreation is the ghost tour – a walking tour of a historical house or city that highlights the location’s macabre past and paranormal pedigree, typically focussing on slavery-related narratives. The tone of the tour is often light-hearted or darkly humorous, and the stories are sometimes accompanied by other forms of recreational activity such as the consumption of alcohol.

Unsurprisingly, such tours have attracted a fair amount of scrutiny, with many critics questioning their value, ethics and impact on the public understanding of the past. But even the most vocal opponents are usually able to recognise the motives behind the practice. Beyond simple voyeurism, dark tourism in the South reflects a popular desire to engage with the history of slavery, tempered by a reluctance to face its horrors head-on.

A group of four people stand inside a historic room with polished wooden floors and carved wooden furniture. Three people gather near a tall window, while another stands by a staircase holding a framed portrait drawing. The room includes an ornate cabinet topped with a large urn and a gold‑framed oval mirror, with a painted portrait hanging beside it. The scene suggests a guided discussion or presentation in a museum‑like setting.

A tour in action at the Myrtles Plantation main house. Such tours have attracted attention – both good and bad – for their focus on the horrors of slavery | Credit: themyrtles.com

“Without slavery there is no South, as a region or an idea,” says Tiya Miles, a bestselling author and Harvard history professor specialising in African-American studies. “But if vacationing tourists must somehow confront the ugliness that repels as well as attracts their notice, they would probably rather do so from a safe emotional distance.”

Beyond simple voyeurism, dark tourism in the South reflects a popular desire to engage with the history of slavery, tempered by a reluctance to face its horrors head-on

Hence the ghost tour – and the proliferation of stories similar to the one told about Chloe at the Myrtles Plantation. These tales are just detailed enough to lend them an air of historical authenticity, but sufficiently vague and fanciful enough to allow us to dismiss them as fiction should we wish.

And if we still can’t shake the uncomfortable feeling that, even if Chloe never existed, someone like her certainly did, and suffered equally – well, we can distract ourselves with a tour guide’s gallows humour, or perhaps a cocktail or two.

Suffice to say, neither my husband nor I met a ghost at the Myrtles Plantation. But we did experience something frighteningly uncanny: an enjoyable night’s stay in a setting that once witnessed the true horrors of slavery.

Ad

Caitlin Blackwell Baines is an art historian and author who specialises in Georgian art and architecture. She is the author of How to Build a Haunted House: The History of a Cultural Obsession (Profile Books, 2025)

Ad

Ad

Loading...

Ad

Loading...