MacDonald's leap to power: the story of the first Labour government

A century ago, Ramsay MacDonald entered 10 Downing Street as Britain’s first Labour prime minister. His rapid rise stunned his rivals. Yet it wasn’t long, writes Richard Toye, before they were preparing their revenge

Published: January 25, 2024 at 4:11 PM

Save

Late in the morning of 22 January 1924, Conservative prime minister Stanley Baldwin stepped out of the rear of Downing Street, hailed a passing taxi and headed to Buckingham Palace for an audience with King George V. Baldwin was making the short journey to hand in his resignation – one taken by so many leaders before and since. But there was one key difference to his experience from those of earlier Tory PMs: this time he was to be succeeded not by a leader of the Conservatives’ long-time opponents, the Liberals, but by Ramsay MacDonald – who would shortly be confirmed as the first Labour Party prime minister in British history.

Ad

These events marked a striking reversal of fortune for MacDonald: less than a decade earlier, his staunch opposition to the First World War had made him one of the most hated men in Britain. He now made the leap to premier without having ever previously held high office.

This was also a moment of truth for the Labour Party itself, less than a quarter of a century old and forming a government for the first time. For many Britons, the all-too-recent horrors of the Bolshevik revolution were proof that socialists, even ostensibly moderate ones, could not be trusted with power. The king, a cousin of the slain Russian royal family, was also apprehensive. During his first audience with MacDonald, he expressed his hope that the prime minister “would do nothing to compel him to shake hands with the murderers of his relatives”.

It was probably inevitable that the Labour Party, representing the organised working class, would one day form a government – but not that this would happen as early as 1924. Had Labour’s Conservative and Liberal opponents played their respective hands differently, the moment of truth could have been significantly postponed.

Poverty and plenty

Understanding the origins of that moment requires a step back to the late 19th century, a time of accelerated technological developments and growing wealth but also of radical inequality. The common phrase ‘poverty in the midst of plenty’ encapsulated the moral case for change. New socialist groups proliferated and trade unions boomed, winning significant victories for unskilled workers.

MacDonald was born in Scotland in 1866, the illegitimate son of a farm labourer and a maidservant. He took an early interest in socialism, but continued to put his faith in cooperation between the Liberal Party and the forces of labour. Eventually, he concluded that the Liberals had little interest in fielding working-class candidates for public office.
In common with many of his generation who urgently sought social progress, he reached the conclusion that an independent party was needed. And in 1900, when the Labour Representation Committee (LRC) – a forerunner of the Labour Party – was formed, MacDonald became its secretary.

Members of the Labour Representation Committee in 1906, including (third left) Ramsay MacDonald. (Photo by Getty Images)

Members of the Labour Representation Committee in 1906, including (third left) Ramsay MacDonald. (Photo by Getty Images)

Three years later, MacDonald struck a deal with the Liberal chief whip, Herbert Gladstone, such that 35 LRC parliamentary candidates ran unopposed by Liberals – an arrangement that proved key to a breakthrough at the 1906 general election, when the LRC won 29 seats and was subsequently renamed the Labour Party. Yet by the time the First World War broke out in 1914, Labour had made limited further progress. Pacifist MacDonald resigned as chairman of the Parliamentary Labour Party (PLP) in opposition to the war, in the process becoming a target for popular hatred. However, his party rival, Arthur Henderson, accepted positions in the Liberal-led wartime coalitions of HH Asquith (May 1915–December 1916) and David Lloyd George (December 1916– December 1918), giving Labour its first taste of life in government.

The party also stood to benefit from the passing of the 1918 Representation of the People Act, which extended the franchise to millions of new voters, including all men over the age of 21 and women over the age of 30 who met certain property qualifications.

A political comeback

By 1922, MacDonald had bounced back. At that year’s general election, Labour – now led by JR Clynes – won 142 seats, becoming the official opposition for the first time. When parliament met following the election, MacDonald was once again chosen as PLP chairman, albeit by just a few votes – other- wise the first Labour prime minister could have been the now-forgotten figure of Clynes, who lacked the force, charisma and eloquence that made MacDonald a far more convincing candidate for Number 10.

Labour’s appeal was boosted by the seeming failures of capitalism, manifested in mass unemployment. Outraged at the Conservative government’s inaction, members of the ‘Red Clydeside’ group of radical MPs stirred up rowdy Commons scenes in protest, presenting themselves as the champions of the poor. To some observers, though, they appeared sour, militant class warriors. The arch-Conservative Morning Post decried their speeches as “examples of Bolshevist frightfulness well calculated for the end in view of disgusting the ‘workers’ (and everybody else) with parliament”.

MacDonald worried about the consequences of such antics, appealing to his MPs “for a greater measure of self-restraint and for a realisation of the fact that when a Labour government arrives it will be greatly hampered if, in the meantime, parliamentary government has been destroyed”.

Clearly, MacDonald believed that the first Labour government was a matter of when, not if – a confidence reflecting his evolutionary vision of socialism. Yet even he must have been surprised by the speed at which events then moved.

In 1923, Baldwin – having been prime minister for only a matter of months – called a snap general election. He had concluded that the high levels of unemployment afflicting Britain could not be solved without the introduction of protectionist tariffs – but this plan, he believed, required the endorsement of the voters before it could be put into action. His startling move had the dual effects of reuniting the Liberals under Asquith’s leadership and giving a fillip to Labour, which broadly shared the Liberals’ free trade values.

Polling took place on 6 December, resulting in one of the great upsets of British political history.

The Conservatives secured 5.5 million votes (38.1 per cent of those cast), Labour 4.4 million (30.5 per cent), and the Liberals 4.3 million (29.6 per cent). This translated into 258 seats for the Conservatives, 191 for Labour, and 159 for the Liberals. Though the Tories lost their majority, they remained the largest party, and Baldwin did not resign immediately. Instead, ministers drew up a King’s Speech – a programme of legislation to put before MPs – thus putting the onus on the Liberals, now effectively kingmakers, to either keep the Conservatives in office or let Labour take over. It was an invidious choice but, despite the unease of some of his supporters, Liberal leader Asquith decided to give MacDonald his chance.

When parliament met in the new year, the government’s defeat set the stage for Baldwin’s cab-ride to the palace as newspaper placards declared “Lenin Dead (official), Ramsay MacDonald Premier”.

According to Jack Lawson, a former miner who now became a junior minister, “The coming of that first Labour government was a terrific shock to the divinely ordained to rule element in the country.” There was certainly something of a change in style, as demonstrated by a story told about the new colonial secretary, JH Thomas. His private secretary, inherited from the previous Conservative minister, was asked how he liked his new boss. “Very much indeed,” he responded. “It’s much more intimate. My old chief used to ring the bell for me. My new chief puts his head round the door of my room, and says: ‘Come ’ere, you b-----!’”

However, the new administration failed to challenge the established political and economic system. With a shortage of experienced personnel, it was necessary to make some appointments from beyond the ranks of the Labour Party; for example, the Liberal grandee Lord Haldane became lord chancellor. MacDonald acted as his own foreign secretary, working tirelessly towards Fran- co-German reconciliation. He sent Arthur Henderson to the Home Office, and made the austere Philip Snowden – another rival of MacDonald – chancellor of the Exchequer. Snowden’s so-called ‘Housewife’s Budget’ cut duties on sugar and tea but did not feature the ‘capital levy’, a tax on fortunes that had previously featured in Labour’s programme yet which was thought to be electorally unpopular. Unemployment benefits were extended and some temporary public works schemes launched but, lacking a majority – and clear policy solutions – the government failed to solve the problem of the dole queue.

Ready to strike

MacDonald himself was hardly able to enjoy his success. Though his daughter Ishbel, one of his five surviving children, served as his hostess in Downing Street, the widowed MacDonald suffered from chronic loneliness, and his low moods sometimes spilled over into bitterness towards his colleagues.

There were increased tensions between the parliamentary and trade union sides of the labour movement, too. Industrial action continued to break out, in spite of ministers’ appeals to union leaders such as Ernest Bevin; to Bevin’s disgust, the government threatened to use the Emergency Powers Act to force striking dockers back to work. However, Labour enjoyed a key domestic success in the form of a Housing Act, pioneered by Clydeside MP John Wheatley, which led to a noted increase in building.

On the international front, MacDonald’s administration took steps that signalled a break with the approaches taken by preceding governments. It moved quickly to bestow diplomatic recognition on the new Union of Soviet Socialist Republics (USSR, or Soviet Union), formed in December 1922. Two treaties were later negotiated with the Soviets to settle past disputes and create new trade relations. MacDonald scrapped plans for a naval base in Singapore (though the Conservatives later reversed this decision). Importantly, working with the French, he also helped win preliminary approval from League of Nations member states for the Geneva Protocol for the Pacific Settlement of International Disputes.

After the Labour government fell later in 1924, its Conservative successor declined to ratify this proposed new mechanism, which would have made arbitration compulsory and bolstered the role of the World Court. Whether the Geneva Protocol would have worked is a moot point, but the fact that the Tories rejected it allowed Labour to develop a narrative in which European peace and disarmament could have been achieved if only the League had been strengthened as the advocates of socialist foreign policy had wished.
Yet with Labour only the second-largest party in parliament, it was inevitable that MacDonald’s government could not last long. While his enemies watched for a moment to strike, the prime minister’s best hope, he believed, was to show that his party was capable of governing and had no intention of indulging in Bolshevik-style experiments. Finally, though, the Conservatives and the Liberals joined forces over an issue that they believed would play out unfavourably to Labour.

JR Campbell, acting editor of the communist newspaper Workers’ Weekly, had been charged with incitement to mutiny as the result of an article he had published urging sol- diers not to fire on strikers. The attorney general, Sir Patrick Hastings, then withdrew the prosecution – a move that could be portrayed as ministers being soft on communism. MacDonald made a (probably unintentionally) misleading statement about his knowledge of the affair and, as anger swelled, the government was heavily defeated in the Commons, triggering a general election. That campaign was marked by a particularly notorious episode that Labour came to regard as a classic example of Tory ‘dirty tricks’.
On 25 October, shortly before polling day, the Daily Mail published “A ‘very secret’ letter of instruction from Moscow, which... discloses a great Bolshevik plot to paralyse the British Army and Navy and to plunge the country into civil war.” This letter, purportedly written to British communists by Grigory Zinoviev of the Communist International (Comintern) movement, was almost certainly forged, probably by someone with connections to Britain’s secret security organisations. Even if the scheme had been real, it would have stood little chance of success – but it played on the genuine fears of many voters, and the Tories made the most of it.

Bruised but defiant

In the event, the election brought a Conservative landslide, ousting MacDonald after just nine and a half months in the top post. Bruised but defiant, he survived to fight another day, serving as the head of another minority government from 1929. Two years later he joined with Tories and Liberals to form the so-called National Government, continuing as prime minister for another four years till 1935, but he was never forgiven by those within the Labour Party who believed he had betrayed them.

Labour, it could be argued, nevertheless owed MacDonald a great deal because of his earlier actions. The result of the autumn 1924 election was far less bad than it first appeared. True, the Conservatives won a highly impressive 419 constituencies and a 48.3 per cent share of the vote – but, though Labour’s representation in the Commons was reduced to just 151 seats, its share of the vote climbed to 33 per cent. The real losers in that election were the Liberals: they took just 40 seats, with their portion of votes cut to 17.6 per cent.
If MacDonald’s plan had been to ensure that Labour would henceforth provide the only electorally credible alternative to the Conservatives, he had succeeded spectacularly. On the face of it, such a short-lived government might seem an abject failure. Taking the long view, though, MacDonald’s determination to showcase Labour’s capacity for steady, competent government proved a remarkable strategic success – one that seeded a century of political strength.

Ad

Richard Toye is professor of history at the University of Exeter. His latest book is Age of Hope: Labour, 1945, and the Birth of Modern Britain (Bloomsbury Continuum, 2023)

Ad

Ad

Loading...

Ad

Loading...