- Home
- Membership
- “He’s making choices that we would perceive as ruthless” | Wolf Hall’s researcher on Thomas Cromwell
“He’s making choices that we would perceive as ruthless” | Wolf Hall’s researcher on Thomas Cromwell
Kirsten Claiden-Yardley, a production researcher on the BBC adaptation of Hilary Mantel’s final novel, The Mirror & the Light, tells us about recreating the world of the Tudors in Wolf Hall.

- Jonathan Wright
Published: November 28, 2024 at 9:39 AM
Save
- Share on facebook
- Share on twitter
- Share on whatsapp
- Email to a friend
It was a bolt out of the blue. When the first series of Wolf Hall was being readied for filming, Kirsten Claiden-Yardley was studying towards her doctorate in Tudor history. Would, the Wolf Hall production team asked, she be interested in answering queries from the show’s director, Peter Kosminsky?
Ad
Naturally, she said yes. When the dramatisation of the third book in Hilary Mantel’s trilogy, The Mirror & the Light, went into production, Yardley, who now works as a historian, researcher and historic buildings consultant, was again on board. Here, she shares the realities of the society in which the real Thomas Cromwell operated.
Part of your job was to help Peter Kosminsky understand the world of Thomas Cromwell. Do we sometimes underestimate how alien it would be for us if we were suddenly transported back to 16th-century England?
The Tudor era is kind of a weird mishmash of both the familiar and utterly unfamiliar. We sometimes see the people as totally alien. And sometimes we go too far that way in that core emotions are often the same.
People are still motivated by love, greed, grief. But we do underestimate the importance of religion, just how ingrained into everyday life religious belief is, and how much people’s days and weeks and months and years were structured around a religious calendar – and particular times of day when you pray.
To what degree would Cromwell’s religious beliefs have driven him? There’s an impression in Hilary Mantel’s books that he kept his personal faith a little under wraps.
Yes, and I don’t think he’s the only one to have done this. In underestimating how important religious beliefs are to people at the time, I think it can be a little easy to dismiss them. Was that really such a driving factor? Was it more to do with greed or desire for political power?
I think most of the people that we come across in Wolf Hall and The Mirror & The Light are deeply religious in their own ways. They may not agree exactly on how they think their religious beliefs should be expressed, there are a lot of debates going on, but they believe what they believe very strongly. It does play a part in driving their actions and their policies.
There have been criticisms that Mantel’s take on Cromwell was too sympathetic, that he was a brutal and ruthless man. What are your thoughts here?
I would definitely agree that he could be quite brutal and ruthless. I don’t think we completely lose that in Hilary Mantel's books, he is still making choices that we would, from our modern perspective, perceive as quite harsh and ruthless. But he wasn’t alone in that. I don’t think you survive at the top of Henry VIII’s court without being ruthless.
After Wolf Hall came out, Diarmaid MacCulloch wrote an incredibly good biography of Cromwell [Thomas Cromwell: A Life]. But when Hilary Mantel started out, he was often seen as the villain in the stories of Anne Boleyn and Thomas More. What Hilary Mantel did was essentially make him into a fully formed person – yes, he is brutal and ruthless, but there are other sides to him as well, that’s not all he’s about.
What about Henry VIII? Was he a monster as he’s sometimes portrayed?
Part of the problem with Henry VIII is there's a tendency to try and get a single answer. When he becomes king in 1509, he’s almost 18 and he’s king until 1547. Trying to distill him down into a simple, one-sentence description just seems like an impossible task to me.
Henry is young in 1509. He's handsome, he’s sporty, he's active, he jousts, he hunts, he’s desirable. You can understand why Catherine of Aragon wants to marry him. He's deeply religious, he’s a defender of the Catholic faith, and this is just so very, very different from what he becomes.
With people and with events, when we look at them from now, we're trying to see a logical pattern, but that’s not how lives work at all. Random things happen and unexpected events. We make choices and we send our lives off down different routes.
What can we say about how Henry later thinks of Cromwell’s fate?
He sometimes regrets that decision. Later [after Cromwell’s fall], he's like, ‘Oh, I wish I had Cromwell.’ Also, it’s a bit of a ‘get out of jail free card’ for Henry that, at that time, people don't blame the king. If you rebel, you can't say that it's the king you don't like, you have to say it's the advisors.
Ad
Kirsten Claiden-Yardley is a Tudor historian and researcher, and production researcher on Wolf Hall: The Mirror and the Light
Authors
Jonathan Wright
Ad
Ad
Loading...
Ad
Loading...