An ancient mystery is hiding under one of Scotland's major archaeological sites – and it's about to be dug up

The Ness of Brodgar was covered over in 2024 to preserve it for future generations. But a new discovery at the edge of the site has brought archaeologists back already

Close-up of archaeologists using hand tools and brushes to excavate a deposit of animal bones, soil and flat stones around Structure 10 at the Ness of Brodgar.

Published: July 1, 2026 at 5:15 PM

Save

The archaeological team had gathered, as they often did at the end of a day’s work, at the pub. In front of them on their table at the Ferry Inn in Stromness, the second-largest town in Scotland's Orkney archipelago, a laptop was open.

Ad

Hours earlier, they had been about five miles to the north-east at the Ness of Brodgar. This network of Neolithic (late Stone Age) buildings on a patch of land between two lochs is widely acknowledged as one of Britain’s, if not the world’s, most important prehistoric sites.

Over two days, the group, from the online archaeological show Time Team, had been slowly driving a quad bike, pulling what appeared to be a large tray over a grassy part of the Ness. It had not been mapped in detail before, and the tray was in fact a powerful ground-penetrating radar that would give them a full 3D image, made up of billions of data points, showing what lay beneath.

John Gater, a Time Team geophysicist for whom the Ness of Brodgar has been his life’s work and passion, was one of those in the pub analysing the finds on the laptop.

His colleagues already knew the results, and he had not realised that they had placed a small piece of black tape over a corner of the computer. Then they removed it, and revealed the surprise.

“I suddenly saw these results,” Gater says, and pauses. “I was quite emotional about it. That sounds over the top, but my mind was racing: ‘What have we mapped?’” Naturally, the team celebrated with a few drams of whisky.

The scans showed what has, somewhat quaintly, been called an “anomaly” – a shape buried on the edge of the Ness that was not previously known. It may end up being more than just an anomaly, however. Depending on what a dig beginning in the next few weeks shows, it could upend the narrative of the Ness of Brodgar.

Geophysicist John Gater stands beside a quad bike fitted with ground-penetrating radar equipment on grassland near the Ness of Brodgar in Orkney.

Geophysicist John Gater stands beside the ground-penetrating radar equipment used to scan an unmapped section of the Ness of Brodgar. The survey revealed an unexpected buried feature that archaeologists are preparing to investigate.
Photograph by Sigurd Towrie

The ‘anomaly’ that could rewrite the Ness story

For centuries, up to the early 2000s, no one had taken much notice of a mound of earth at the isthmus where the Ness is located. It had always appeared to be just that: an indistinct bump, albeit one in proximity to two important stone circles – the Ring of Brodgar, which dates back to the third millennium BC, and the Stones of Stenness, which, at about 5,000 years old, is probably the oldest henge in Britain.

That bump held its own secrets, however, as an archaeological survey revealed in 2002. It showed evidence of a dense cluster of structures under the ground, and further digs starting in 2004 eventually revealed the remains of close to 40 buildings.

At its heyday, the site would have been impressively tall and complex, layered with tiled roofs, coloured walls and decorated stone, suggesting it held a sense of importance to the community going back millennia.

Archaeologist Nick Card, of the University of the Highlands and Islands, has worked on the site since those early days and will be involved in this summer’s dig. His enthusiasm for the Ness of Brodgar shines through from the moment he begins talking about it.

“The Ness has transformed our understanding of many different aspects of the Neolithic in Orkney, and further afield,” he says. “It is a place where the evidence transforms our picture of social life and social change in the Neolithic, and the nature of contact and communication at broader scales.”

Aerial view of archaeologists excavating stone-built Neolithic structures at the Ness of Brodgar, with exposed walls, paving stones, tools and trenches visible across the site.

Archaeologists work among the exposed stone remains of Structure 27 at the Ness of Brodgar, a Neolithic site in Orkney whose buildings have transformed understanding of Stone Age life in Britain. Photograph by Scott Pike

Why the site was covered over

But Card’s work on the Ness always had an end point, or at least a pause point. Exposing the fragile structures to the fierce elements at this meeting point of the North Sea and the Atlantic Ocean brought the risk of erosion and so, in 2024, a perhaps surprising decision was taken: the main site was covered over again. Doing so also allowed the archaeological teams to analyse and write up everything they had discovered over two decades.

“One of the reasons we covered it over was for it to be locked there for future generations, with better techniques, better technology and better science to actually deal with it in future,” Card says.

But even as the site was being covered up, there was still a sense among those who worked there that plenty more lay undiscovered. Time Team offered to fund the 3D scan of an adjoining section of the site measuring roughly 14 metres by 12. Now broadcast exclusively on YouTube since leaving Channel 4 in 2013, the programme has hundreds of thousands of subscribers, whose contributions will also fund this summer’s work.

Over four weeks, the team of up to a dozen archaeologists will remove a layer of top soil, before digging a small trench through the site, which will be excavated in sections, down to about half a metre.

“When we closed the site up in 2024, we always said: ‘That’s it, never go back, no more digging’,” says Card. “But the nature of this anomaly, we think, could add another chapter to the Ness.”

Wide aerial view of the Ness of Brodgar excavation site on a narrow strip of land between two lochs in Orkney, with trenches, stone remains, buildings and surrounding fields visible.

The Ness of Brodgar lies on a narrow isthmus between two lochs in Orkney, close to some of Britain’s most important Neolithic monuments. Excavations here have revealed a dense complex of ancient stone buildings. Photograph by Tom O’Brien

Caution before a new excavation

What exactly that chapter could be is a matter of some secrecy and caution. Everyone seems to agree that what lies under the ground is not likely to pre-date the previous Neolithic discoveries at the Ness, but it certainly is unusual.

“What’s different is we’re no longer seeing these rectilinear shapes, these large Neolithic buildings,” says John Gater. “We’re seeing something that is totally different that hasn’t been seen before on the Ness. It’s the sort of response that, although it looks very clear on the radar, there’s lots of different explanations.”

If it is indeed later than the Neolithic period, the new structure could suggest a continued occupation of the site that had not been previously known, and hint at an appreciation of the site’s significance that continued across centuries.

But that’s as much as anyone is willing to discuss – due partly to a natural caution held by archaeologists and geophysicists who don’t wish to speak too soon, and due partly to an eagerness not to reveal more before new episodes of Time Team are broadcast.

The archaeological urge not to jump the gun is understandable. Gater says that once his team carried out scans on a site that might have contained Roman ruins. They were keeping an eye out for typically straight Roman lines underground, only for scans to pick up unusual curved features. Inevitably, they were excited by this surprising discovery.

“What we had was the white lines of an old football pitch,” he says. “Where they’d been putting down lime to mark the penalty area, and so on. It had changed the moisture content of the soil.”

Even so, Gater says he is “nervously excited” about the work ahead on the site he has known for close to 50 years, and acknowledges it could lead to even further exploration.

Ad

“The rest of the landscape could be looked at, and that would be a 20-year project, I imagine,” he says. “I’ll probably be using my zimmer frame to get around, or a mobile scooter – and I could have the antenna attached to the back of that.”

Authors

Roland HughesFreelance journalist

Roland is a freelance journalist who has previously worked as a senior writer and editor with BBC News and Apple News.

Ad

Ad

Loading...

Ad

Loading...