- Home
- Membership
- From ancient China to modern America: an astonishing history of censorship
From ancient China to modern America: an astonishing history of censorship
A mistrust of ‘experts’ and ‘intellectuals’ has recently crystallised into US government interventions targeting academic institutions. Emily Knox and Joan Scott share their thoughts with Danny Bird about the troubling history of anti-intellectualism

Published: April 29, 2026 at 5:00 PM
Save
- Share on facebook
- Share on twitter
- Share on whatsapp
- Email to a friend
Danny Bird: Anti-intellectualism can feel like quite a contemporary concern – but when did this phenomenon emerge?
Joan Scott: It goes back a long way. In the case of the United States, a key reference is Anti-intellectualism in American Life by Richard Hofstadter, published in 1963 in the wake of the McCarthy anti-communist hearings. I return to it often. Hofstadter traces anti-intellectualism almost to the nation’s beginnings, particularly in debates over education. Attempts to centralise schooling repeatedly provoked hostile reactions from local communities determined to control what their children were taught. Hofstadter locates this strain chiefly among non-elite, less formally educated groups who are suspicious of expertise and claims to superior competence, and wary of those in elite positions.
Ad
The US therefore has a long history of anti-intellectualism, though it also appears in different forms elsewhere. France may be something of an exception – as a historian, I have seen philosophical disputes conducted at every level of French society in a way quite unlike anything in the US. In any case, though the tradition of anti-intellectualism is long-standing, we may now be experiencing it at its most acute.
Emily Knox: When I think about anti-intellectualism, I see a rift. There is a fear that, if someone becomes more educated or begins to listen to experts, a break opens within their community. This is especially visible with first-generation university students, who can feel pulled away from their families and local ties. In many cases, anti-intellectualism grows from that sense of separation. It is rooted less in abstract questions of trust than in fear of loss, distance and change. Viewing it in those terms helps us to understand it more clearly.
Has it commonly been during times of upheaval – such as religious conflicts, revolutions and the rise of authoritarian and populist regimes – when academic freedom has been attacked?
EK: Yes. One of the earliest and most well-known recorded instances of book burning occurred in 213 BC under China’s first imperial dynasty, when the emperor, Qin Shi Huang, suppressed dissent by executing scholars and destroying their texts.
Scholars are often targeted during periods of unrest or reactionary upheaval. In moments of crisis, people look for someone to blame: where did these ideas come from? Suspicion frequently falls on education and on those who produce and transmit knowledge. Across history, intellectual life repeatedly becomes suspect when societies fracture.

An 18th-century illustration shows books burned and scholars buried on the orders of the first Chinese emperor, Qin Shi Huang, in 213 BC – an early example of the suppression of intellectual activity (Image by Alamy)
JS: I think it stems from the association between scholarship and criticism. From the outset, the scholar’s role has been to reflect on and critique the conditions in which people live. To pursue truth, however defined, is to question authority, and that questioning has long been linked to education.
It is this critical function that makes scholars targets. As Immanuel Kant argued in The Conflict of the Faculties at the end of the 18th century, philosophers are uniquely placed to tell rulers what is wrong and what ought to be done. That task does not belong to theology or to the more practical disciplines.

German philosopher Immanuel Kant, pictured in 1765, stated that philosophers are uniquely placed to tell rulers what is wrong, says Joan Scott (Image by Getty Images)
This year marks 250 years since the American Revolution, which was led by a group of individuals strongly influenced by Enlightenment ideals. But did any anti-intellectual responses emerge from that upheaval?
EK: The American context is particularly difficult because the revolution was incomplete in many ways. The promises of the founding documents are continually invoked, yet often fall short. For black Americans, the original revolution did not apply; another, still ongoing struggle was necessary. The more approximate parallel is the Reconstruction era (1865–77) after the Civil War, when American society attempted to redefine the rights of black people – a process still unfinished today.
We are now a generation beyond the civil rights movement, which itself was incomplete. Today, we see reactionary efforts to undo its achievements: attacks on the Voting Rights Act, resistance to feminist advances, and hostility toward LGBTQIA+ rights. Understanding this requires grappling with history, which Americans often struggle to do.
The controversy over the 1619 Project illustrates this: presenting American history from a non-triumphalist perspective, centring it beyond the founding fathers, provoked deep resistance. Nikole Hannah-Jones originally created it as a New York Times Magazine special, marking the arrival of the first enslaved Africans in Virginia as the starting point of American history. She produced a series of essays centring the experiences of enslaved people and their descendants across time. It represents Hannah-Jones’s effort to reframe American history through a new, often contested lens.

A freedmen’s school in the US, c1868. “After the Civil War, American society attempted to redefine the rights of black people – a process still unfinished today,” says Emily Knox (Image by Alamy)
The project later expanded into a full book and a children’s edition, and quickly became a lightning rod, particularly among critics of what is called ‘critical race theory’.
Similarly, images from the civil rights movement can unsettle people because they expose their own families’ histories, which remain raw for those who lived through it. Coming to terms with these histories is a profoundly difficult, ongoing challenge in the US.
JS: Many of the critics of the 1619 Project who saw themselves as progressive or left-leaning attacked it not for ideological reasons but by accusing it of factual errors. In doing so, I believe some of them may have been denying the underlying biases they bring to the study of history themselves: a commitment to a triumphalist, progressivist vision of America. It illustrates how historians can obscure the assumptions that shape their own work while critiquing others.
Why have books so often been targeted during waves of anti-intellectualism?
EK: I am fascinated by the book as a technology: it collapses time and space, allowing us to access what people thought centuries ago. Books are particularly powerful in the Global North, shaped by the influence of Christianity, especially Protestantism. In my work on the Reformation, I emphasise two doctrines: sola scriptura, the idea that one can save one’s soul through reading [scripture]; and the ‘priesthood of all believers’ – the principle that no intermediary is required between God and people, reader and text.
Books occupy a unique place in our lives. I often ask students if they break the bindings of their books; some are horrified by the idea while others are indifferent. Unlike other objects, the way we engage with texts shapes how we understand ourselves. That is why books are frequently banned: they are among the most powerful tools for shaping thought and identity. Control over knowledge has always been exercised through text, because this is how ideas are communicated, shared and contested.
Censorship is another method often deployed to actively police the public understanding of reality. Where does this practice originate?
EK: The origin of the term stretches back to the ancient Roman censor – the magistrate responsible for overseeing public morality. Authorised knowledge has always been central not only to authoritarian control but even to self-identifying democratic governments when they define what information is sanctioned and what is forbidden.
Historically, this is seen in the ‘king’s imprimatur’ – the official seal approving a text. Today, the same principle appears in cases such the Epstein files: redactions signal what the government deems authorised for public access versus knowledge it withholds. Often, authorised knowledge focuses on victims, while information about perpetrators is restricted. This illustrates how governments generally manage and control knowledge.
JS: Historically, almost every authoritarian regime has relied on censorship to impose its will. This illustrates how law can both censor knowledge and impose a singular view of human identity. Similar patterns appear throughout history: during the French Revolution, the Jacobins dictated what could be taught about society, politics and relationships; Maoist China imposed its ideological framework on education. Censorship has consistently been a key tool of authoritarian regimes for controlling thought, knowledge and social norms.

A participant in the 28 August 2025 March on Wall Street, a rally protesting against US government policies towards Diversity, Equity and Inclusion programmes (Image by Getty Images)
The study of history itself has often been at the forefront of anti-intellectual crusades. How can our comprehension of the past be sanitised or distorted by political pressures – and what are the consequences?
JS: This raises a complex question, because I don’t believe in a single, objective truth of history. The history we write always reflects the ethical positions and values we bring to it. For example, the 1619 Project cannot be told without addressing both the history of slavery and its ongoing legacy of racism. My choices in research and teaching are guided by these values.
There is no history without values – not in the sense of imposing an ‘official’ version but in recognising that the questions we ask about the past are shaped by the present. This is why it is crucial that the stories we teach, whether to children or the wider public, acknowledge the contemporary concerns that motivate them. Criticisms framed as objections to ‘presentism’ misunderstand this: the past exists only as we interpret it.
So, in response to critics of undertakings such as the 1619 Project, the debate should centre not on alleged factual errors but on the values and principles that inform one’s approach to history. That is the lens through which I, as a professional historian, understand the importance of my work.
EK: My work focuses on very recent history. For example, I’m interested in how the Covid-19 pandemic will be presented to children today. The youngest kids who truly remember it are now around eight to 10 years old. For many in school, the pre-pandemic world is already history.
Recent events, such as the 6 January 2021 attack on the US Capitol [by supporters of Donald Trump who believed the 2020 presidential election was ‘stolen’], illustrate how contested history can be. Even when reported widely, narratives vary: should words such as ‘insurrection’ be used to describe that episode? How do we interpret the actions of those involved, and the political consequences? These debates will eventually filter down into schoolbooks and children’s literature, and that is where history becomes contested at the community level, not just among scholars.

Supporters of Donald Trump storm the US Capitol on 6 January 2021, aiming to overturn Joe Biden’s election win. Such events demonstrate just how contested even recent history can be, says Emily Knox (Image by Getty Images)
Many students note that history covered in formal lessons in the US often stops at 9/11, leaving everything since then largely unexamined. My work explores how recent events are already history, how their presentation is debated, and how these debates shape what children and the public understand about our shared past.
JS: Statues are often used to memorialise figures as heroes of the nation, state or community. For example, Donald Trump has proposed marking the country’s 250th anniversary with a National Garden of American Heroes featuring 250 statues of people he considers important in US history. Meanwhile, statues depicting historical figures such as Christopher Columbus are being restored, alongside some of Confederate generals that had been removed or relocated to museums. In my view, plaques in such institutions explaining those people’s actions are far more appropriate than central heroic displays.
The controversy over Columbus illustrates how historical narratives shift: he was once taught as the discoverer of America, but recognition of Native American perspectives has reshaped that story. President Trump’s recognition of Columbus Day, while not acknowledging Indigenous Peoples’ Day, reflects the politics of history.
Television documentaries such as Ken Burns’ The American Revolution (2025) show how historical scholarship can reshape public understanding. Burns highlights slavery, Native American displacement and figures including Crispus Attucks, the first casualty of the revolution, who happened to be of African and Native American heritage – a critical intervention that revises the traditional triumphalist narrative.
Why and when do anti-intellectual movements demonise scholars and experts as ‘out-of-touch’ elites? Is it specifically during times of economic or other social crises?
EK: You can’t discuss anti-intellectualism without considering class. The intellectual class is rarely working class; it is defined less by economics and more by markers of middle or upper-middle-class life. Intellectuals work with their minds rather than their hands, spend years in study – a luxury that many cannot afford – and are often associated with habits such as publishing, reading and other cultural signifiers.
These markers set them apart. My father, for example, was the first in our family to earn a PhD in mathematics, and for years he was told he was ‘wasting his time’ instead of getting a job. Anti-intellectualism is often rooted in the perception of these class-based privileges, yet that dimension is not always acknowledged in discussions of the phenomenon.
JS: Anti-intellectualism can emerge during times of crisis, but not always. Sometimes it is used opportunistically to advance a political agenda. Take the McCarthy era: the Cold War generated anxieties about communism, but it was Joseph McCarthy who manufactured a crisis, investigating and summoning individuals, ruining careers and dominating public attention for a decade.

Joseph McCarthy’s anti-communist crusade was, says Emily Knox, driven as much by personal opportunism as genuine political crisis (Image by Getty Images)
A similar pattern exists in higher education today. The sector has long faced structural challenges, including reduced state and federal funding, a shift to student debt, and widespread financial insecurity. However the Trump administration’s higher education interventions have transformed these ongoing difficulties into what I believe is a full-blown crisis. Political opportunism, layered onto long-term structural pressures, plays a crucial role in the rise of anti-intellectualism.
The internet was once hailed as a means of democratising access to information. However, in recent years it has gained a reputation for transmitting disinformation and conspiracy theories. How has this enabled anti-intellectualism to amplify distrust of expertise?
EK: A good example comes from Reddit, where the AskHistorians subreddit is highly regulated: answers require citations and are usually provided by professional historians. It allows people to ask complex questions and ensures careful, informed responses. Yet Reddit also hosts substantial misinformation, especially on health topics, making it a fascinating place to observe how knowledge and misunderstanding can coexist.
Subreddits that encourage questions – for example, NoStupidQuestions and explainlikeimfive [years old] – provide spaces for people to seek understanding in a non-judgmental way. These forums highlight the importance of proactive,
clear communication, rather than leaving people to rely solely on news or social media snippets.
Is there a consistent thread that unites all of the anti-intellectual movements throughout history?
EK: It’s largely about control. Take the Index Librorum Prohibitorum (Index of Forbidden Books) compiled by the Catholic church, for example. It was created in response to Protestantism, to assert authority over ideas that the Catholic church could no longer directly control. The logic was simple: if people couldn’t read certain texts, they wouldn’t question doctrine, and the church’s authority would remain intact.
In practice, this often backfired. Listing a book could make it more appealing. Even in the medieval period, putting a book on the Index often simply drew attention to it, making people want to read it. Attempts to control thought through banning texts rarely work as intended.
Emily JM Knox is a professor in the School of Information Sciences at the University of Illinois, Urbana-Champaign. The second edition of Book Banning in 21st-century America was published by Bloomsbury in January 2026
Joan Wallach Scott is professor emerita in the Institute for Advanced Study at Princeton University. Her books include Knowledge, Power, and Academic Freedom (Columbia University Press, 2019)
Ad
This article was first published in the April 2026 issue of HistoryExtra Magazine
Ad
Ad
Loading...
Ad
Loading...