George III vs America: was the British king to blame for the loss of the 13 colonies?

The US Declaration of Independence was formally adopted on one famous day in July 1776. Yet this celebrated event was the product of years of misunderstandings and escalating tensions. On the 250th anniversary of the birth of a nation, George Goodwin traces the evolution of one of the most consequential documents in history

A historical painting shows a crowded assembly room where men in 18th‑century clothing gather around a long green‑covered table. At the centre, one man stands with an arm raised and his other hand on his chest, appearing to deliver a forceful speech. The men around him react with raised hands, leaning forward or turning toward him, creating a sense of lively debate. Papers and books lie on the table, and the room feels formal and energetic, capturing a moment of political decision‑making.

Published: June 20, 2026 at 1:00 PM

Save

This July, Americans will be casting their minds back 250 years in commemoration of one extraordinary event. A raft of celebrations – from a nationwide block party to fireworks at Mount Rushmore – will pay homage to the moment, on 4 July 1776, when representatives of the colonies met in Pennsylvania State House, Philadelphia and formally adopted the Declaration of Independence.

Ad

Yet, as we look back at the Declaration from the vantage point of two-and-a-half centuries, it is worth considering how it came into being and how it has become one of the most celebrated documents in world history. Initially, it was the product of the misunderstandings, escalating tensions and missed opportunities within the deteriorating relationship between the Kingdom of Great Britain and its American colonies. But it has become the forerunner and inspiration of around 120 political declarations across the world.

The change in the relationship between Britain and its transatlantic colonies was very rapid indeed. At the conclusion of the Seven Years’ War in 1763, Britain had defeated France, then the greatest military power on the European continent, and almost negated its role in North America. In that achievement, it had worked closely with its American colonies and with Massachusetts in particular. Yet by 1775, British colonists in America were at war with their fellow Britons across the Atlantic, with the first blood spilled on Massachusetts soil, at Lexington and Concord.

A photograph shows a red‑brick historic building with white trim and a tall clock tower rising above it. The tower is topped with a slender spire, and warm lights illuminate the building against a deepening blue evening sky. Bare tree branches frame the scene, and a mix of older and modern buildings sits quietly in the background. The overall mood is calm and dignified, with the landmark standing out in the twilight.

It was in the Pennsylvania State House – now Independence Hall – that representatives of the colonies approved the Declaration of Independence, following weeks of wrangling | Credit: Dreamstime

The essential cause was a combination of the financial and the constitutional. From the perspective of successive British governments during the 1760s and early 1770s, there was an urgent need to fund the continuing presence of British troops on American soil through a succession of taxes, as they sought to protect the gains of 1763. From the perspective of the colonists, there was opposition rising to fury that the funding was to be raised by direct taxation by London, with a complete disregard for the royally chartered rights of the colonial assemblies to tax themselves.

For the colonists, the key issue was about rights and not money. When the Sons of Liberty shouted “No taxation without representation”, they did not mean that they wanted to be represented in parliament, but rather that they opposed being arbitrarily taxed by an institution in which they were not represented.

Radical opposition

The damage to the transatlantic relationship increased with each imposition, as did popular belief in the opposition of radical politicians. That the potential volume of protest remained strongest in Massachusetts was due to grievances against local governors greatly multiplying those against the ministers in London – and because it was enhanced through the political skill of radicals such as Samuel Adams, Joseph Warren and John Adams. Then, in 1773, Lord North’s government introduced the infamous Tea Act, which sparked the Boston Tea Party, the best-known colonial American protest of them all.

From a London perspective, the Tea Act benefited both the home country and its American colonies. This was because exporting a vast amount of East India Company tea directly to America would both save the company from bankruptcy and give the Americans a far cheaper product.

But for the Americans, in general, it was, once again, not about the money. For them, the tax represented yet another attack on their Chartered Rights. As Benjamin Franklin explained with a mixture of anger and disbelief: “[They] continue the duty there to keep up the exercise of the right… They believe that 3d in a pound of tea, of which one does not drink perhaps 10lb in a year, is sufficient to overcome all the patriotism of an American.” However, in Massachusetts, there were two added financial factors. First, some merchants had been making a fortune through smuggling Dutch colony tea, which was now more expensive than the East Indian. Second, among the money-making distributors of the Company’s tea were the sons of the hated governor of Massachusetts Bay, Thomas Hutchinson.

A pencil sketch shows a group of men standing around watching another man forcing tea down the throat of another

Lord North pours tea down America’s throat in a cartoon in The London Magazine, 1774. His actions would trigger the Boston Tea Party, “the best-known colonial American protest of them all” | Credit: Alamy

The reaction to the Tea Act was definitive. On 16 December 1773, 342 chests of tea were dumped into Boston harbour. The British government’s reaction was then similarly uncompromising, as they introduced a series of Coercive Acts that suspended Massachusetts’ administration and its trade. All these were enforced through military rule by British troops in what amounted to a 180-degree turn. The troops had originally been dispatched to Boston as its citizens’ long-term protectors. Now they had become their occupiers and potential aggressors.

A destructive fate

It was the Coercive Acts that brought the 13 colonies together in a defensive pact. This was made clear in the ‘Address to the People of Great Britain’ that was delivered by New York’s John Jay on 21 October 1774, at the First Continental Congress of delegates from all the colonies. Dedicating his remarks to “Friends and fellow subjects” in Britain itself, Jay stated that “by the destruction of the trade of Boston, the ministry have endeavoured to induce submission to their measures. The like fate may befall us all.”

British troops had been sent to Boston as its protectors; now they were its occupiers

With the British general Gage determined to seize colonial artillery and its gunpowder, and the armed and highly trained American militias equally determined to bar their way, a flashpoint was almost inevitable. It occurred at Lexington and triggered a civil war between the British subjects of King George III.

In contrast to the absolutist kings of France and Spain, George III was, by 18th-century standards, a constitutional monarch. As Lord Hillsborough described from his own cabinet experience, the king would “conform to his ministers, though he will argue with them, and very sensibly; but if they adhere to their own opinion, he will say ‘Well. Do you choose it should be so? Then let it be.’”

A formal painted portrait shows a royal figure dressed in elaborate ceremonial clothing. They wear a richly patterned golden garment beneath a white robe trimmed with black spots, and a large white bow sits at the neck. A heavy chain of office with dark blue and gold medallions drapes across the chest. Behind them, a column and draped fabric create a grand, stately backdrop that emphasises their status and authority.

Early on, many American colonists saw George III as the best hope of rapprochement with Britain. By 1776, the king had become the principal target of their ire | Credit: Getty Images

In those terms, it was right that the American colonies should consider the armed conflict that erupted in 1775 to be against the ministerial government in London and not against the king. This view was also in accord with the colonists’ concept of the king as the father of all his subjects and the ultimate protector of their assemblies against the claims of the Westminster parliament. Benjamin Franklin, for one, still believed this as late as 1773, when he described King George as “perhaps the only chance America has for obtaining soon the redress she aims at”.

Divorce proceedings

The journey from Tea Party to independence

16 December 1773: Enraged by British taxation and the perceived quashing of colonial rights, the Sons of Liberty dump 342 chests of tea into Boston harbour 1774: The British government’s decision to implement the Coercive Acts – suspending Massachusetts’ administration and its trade – ramps up tensions with the colonists 19 April 1775: The battle of Lexington and Concord signals the beginning of outright hostilities between the American colonists and British forces 8 July 1775: The Second Continental Congress signs the Olive Branch Petition, a doomed attempt to avoid further conflict with Britain. George III refuses to read it 23 August 1775: Ill feeling intensifies following George III’s ‘Proclamation for Supressing Rebellion and Sedition’, in which he declares the colonies to be in “open and avowed rebellion” 10 January 1776: The pamphlet Common Sense, written by the English-born Thomas Paine, questions the very purpose of monarchy. Many radicals view it as a call to arms 10 May 1776: John Adams and Richard Henry Lee of Virginia introduce a resolution allowing each colony to create a new provincial government – one not subject to the British crown 2 July 1776: The Congress votes to approve a resolution of independence

4 July 1776: In the Pennsylvania State House, Philadelphia, representatives of the 13 colonies formally adopt the Declaration of Independence

9 July 1776: After being read the Declaration of Independence, some troops of George Washington’s Continental Army join citizens in “dethroning” the statue of George III in New York

A cleverer – or perhaps more stupid – monarch than the legalistic George III might have intervened. But when he was presented with the Continental Congress’s ‘Olive Branch Petition’ in the summer of 1775, he avoided hearing it, as that would have involved acting against his own parliament. Instead, George issued, on behalf of his government, ‘A Proclamation for Supressing Rebellion and Sedition’ that declared the colonies to be in “open and avowed rebellion”.

At the beginning of 1776, details of the king’s speech at the opening of parliament on 26 October 1775 reached the colonists. This was notable for its aggression and even more so for being from the king himself. In his role as sovereign head of the British armed forces, King George had announced his determination that foreign mercenary troops would be used against his British American subjects. The reaction of George Washington, who was at that point besieging British troops in Boston, was sarcastic in the extreme: “We are at length favoured with a sight of his majesty’s most gracious speech, breathing sentiments of tenderness and compassion for his deluded American subjects; the echo is not yet come to hand; but we know what it must be.”

An irascible Englishman

There was indeed an echo, and it was immediate, in the form of a long pamphlet called Common Sense. This happened to be published at the very moment that the king’s speech arrived on American shores, matching it in ferocity and mockingly questioning the very purpose of monarchy. Common Sense was so well written that people supposed that surely Benjamin Franklin must be its author. In fact, it was the handiwork of an irascible English jobbing journalist named Thomas Paine, and it was through the powerful medium of the newspapers that it reached a mass audience.

A painted portrait shows a man with shoulder‑length hair wearing a reddish‑brown coat trimmed with fur and a white cravat at his neck. He is shown from the chest up against a soft brown background that keeps the focus on his face. His expression is calm and thoughtful, giving the image a quiet, reflective mood.

Benjamin Franklin was among the most high-profile opponents of the Tea Act and scoffed at the idea that it might actually benefit the American colonists | Credit: Getty Images

Common Sense took into the public sphere the extraordinary change that the more radical of the American leaders had begun contemplating privately: nothing less than the permanent removal of the monarchy.

However, many of their fellow Congressmen had an additional concern to add to their great anxiety that rebellion against the most powerful nation in the world would fail. This was their fear that the rebellion itself could lead to the collapse of all authority, including their own. For there were strong internal pressures: the danger of an uprising from the enslaved African population and from dispossessed Native American tribes; armed attacks from that part of the population, possibly equivalent to those in rebellion, who were loyalists; and, not least, the fundamental differences among the hitherto individually orientated and often highly competitive colonies themselves.

Many colonists feared that rebellion could lead to the collapse of all authority, including their own

Survival of the cause

Conversely, these were the self-same reasons why the more radical Patriots from New England and the leading colony of Virginia, in particular, believed that the survival of the cause depended on binding the colonies together politically. George Washington, who had successfully concluded his siege of Boston in March, was clear in his own mind and was becoming hopeful of his more conservative fellow Virginians, when he wrote the following in a letter dated 1 April 1776: “My countrymen I know, from their form of government and steady attachment heretofore to royalty, will come reluctantly into the idea of independency; but time and persecution brings many wonderful things to pass; and by private letters which I have lately received from Virginia, I find Common Sense is working a powerful change there in the minds of many men.”

A close‑up image shows the title page of an old printed pamphlet. The text appears in bold, serif type, arranged in centred lines on a pale background. The largest words read “COMMON SENSE,” followed by smaller lines addressed “TO THE INHABITANTS OF AMERICA.” The layout is simple and formal, giving the page a strong, declarative feel.

Thomas Paine’s pamphlet Common Sense galvanised resistance to British rule among the colonies | Credit: Getty Images

On 10 May 1776, John Adams of Massachusetts and Richard Henry Lee of Virginia made the first moves towards independence by introducing into Congress the resolution allowing each colony to create a new provincial government in the event of the existing ones refusing to act under their own authority rather than that of the crown. It passed with a majority, but in the face of vigorous protest from the greater part of the Pennsylvania delegation.

With Congress also being in Philadelphia, Adams was able to act quickly. Just five days later, Congress passed his “Preamble” that should the Pennsylvania Assembly refuse to comply then it would need to be replaced by a new government. Under pressure from the radicals in Congress and reinforced by the direct action of the Philadelphia Sons of Liberty and the newspapers they controlled – with all now acting under “The Authority of the People” – the Pennsylvania Assembly was at length persuaded to agree.

The next logical step was for Richard Henry Lee to introduce a resolution for independence, which he did on 7 June. This further increased the heat of the debate that was already well under way, with many Congressmen and those they represented feeling they were being led further than they wished to travel. Thus it was resolved on 10 June that final consideration of the proposition should be postponed until 1 July to allow full reflection by those Assemblies who had still failed to decide. However, on the very next day, 11 June, Congress also appointed a five-man committee to prepare a Declaration of Independence.

A historical painting shows five men in 18th‑century clothing gathered around a table in a warmly lit room. One man holds a document while the others listen closely, leaning in or standing nearby as if engaged in serious discussion. The table is covered with a patterned cloth, and the room includes details like a tall clock, a fireplace with books and flowers on the mantel, and a decorative screen. The scene feels formal and thoughtful, capturing an important moment of decision‑making.

The ‘Committee of Five’ – Robert Livingston, Roger Sherman, John Adams, Thomas Jefferson and Benjamin Franklin – draft the Declaration of Independence, as shown in a 19th-century painting | Credit: Bridgeman Images

But matters were far from clear-cut when the vote on independence was finally taken on 1 July. Pennsylvania and South Carolina were against, Delaware was divided and New York abstained. Another vote was required the next day. Yet, after additional debate, the views of the leading colonies of Virginia and Massachusetts and the bulk of the remainder held sway, and the doubters fell in with the majority. There just remained the abstention of New York – and that only for want of further instructions from its Provincial Congress. It was now time to consider the work of the Declaration Committee.

The committee had members from all three colonial regions: New England was represented by John Adams (Massachusetts) and Roger Sherman (Connecticut); the Middle Colonies by Benjamin Franklin (Pennsylvania) and Robert R Livingston (New York); and the South by Thomas Jefferson of Virginia. As their final document was, for obvious and necessary political reasons, formally presented as one agreed by them all, it was not understood to be the work of Thomas Jefferson until the 1790s. Some had previously thought it to have been written by Benjamin Franklin. In fact, Franklin had just offered one (exceptionally significant) change to its most famous paragraph. With his replacement of “sacred and undeniable” with “self-evident”, the foundational basis changed from one based on religion to one founded on natural law.

Delayed reaction

“We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their creator with certain unalienable rights, that among these are life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness.” These words – the most famous in the entire Declaration of Independence – would go on to characterise the United States as a beacon of libertarian individualism for itself and for the world. Yet they did not take on that central importance until well into the 19th century. As Abraham Lincoln put it in 1857: “The assertion that ‘all men are created equal’ was of no practical use in effecting our separation from Great Britain; and it was placed in the Declaration, not for that, but for future use.”

In 1776, it was critically important that the separation of the United States from Britain be managed in a way that not only united the States but also ensured the practical, if still unofficial, support of the monarchical powers of France and Spain. Paine’s Common Sense had succeeded in many American eyes in diminishing the appeal of relying on a king to act as the benevolent father of all his subjects. Yet such sentiments were in no way suitable for the monarchs of France and Spain.

A historical painting shows a procession of soldiers on horseback moving down a wide city street lined with tall brick buildings. At the centre, a commanding officer in a blue uniform rides a white horse, leading the troops. Crowds of people stand on both sides of the street, cheering and waving early American flags. The atmosphere feels celebratory and triumphant, with sunlight breaking through a partly cloudy sky.

By the time George Washington entered New York in triumph in 1783 – shown above in a 19th-century portrait – the general had fully replaced George III as America’s figure of moral authority | Credit: Getty Images

Thus, it was essential that the Declaration should ascribe villainy to Britain’s monarch and not to the institution of monarchy itself. In short, George III should no longer be regarded as a monarch aligned with William and Mary and their constitutional settlement of 1689, but rather as a malignant ruler in the mould of James II & VII. It is, therefore, no surprise that John Locke’s Second Treatise of Government, with its emphasis on the importance of a ruler gaining the consent of the governed, should be foundational to the Declaration.

Judgment day in New York

In his A Summary View of the Rights of British America, published in 1774, Thomas Jefferson had stated that “it is neither our wish nor our interest to separate from [Great Britain]”, and enunciated the view that the monarch was passively failing his American subjects. By the time of the Declaration of Independence, Jefferson had decided that King George had now taken the most active of roles, and should be judged accordingly.

Though some of Jefferson’s more extreme accusations had been removed, the final Declaration was still clear as to who was to blame for “the establishment of an absolute tyranny over these states”. In a reversal of the normal rule for kings, George III was to take all the blame for his ministers’ decisions – as well as his own.

The king was to take all the blame for his ministers’ decisions, as well as those he’d made himself

The king’s equestrian statue in New York would feel the full force of that judgment just a few days later, following the reading of the Declaration to the city’s inhabitants and the troops of General Washington’s Continental Army. These soldiers and citizens dragged the statue off its pedestal and cast it to the ground. In a sense, George III was turned on himself, because those pieces of the statue not taken by scavengers were made into 42,000 lead bullets to fire at the king’s troops.

A lively historical painting shows a crowd of people pulling down a large equestrian statue. Ropes are tied around the mounted figure, and groups of men strain together to drag it from its pedestal. Women and children stand nearby watching, while others cheer or gesture. The scene takes place in a busy urban square with buildings and a fenced area in the background, capturing a dramatic moment of public action and political emotion.

New Yorkers pull down the city’s equestrian statue of George III following a public recital of the Declaration of Independence, 9 July 1776. By now, the king had become a hate figure for many colonists | Credit: Alamy

The Declaration of Independence did help to bind the United States together in a defensive pact through Congress, though each state continued to regard its own self as sovereign. In contrast, official support from France and Spain would have to wait – after all, according to the diplomatic protocol of the time, a nation state could not be officially recognised as independent until it was regarded as self-sustaining.

It took Britain’s disastrous defeat to the American Continental Army at Saratoga in 1777, the naked self-interest of Britain’s enemies, and Benjamin Franklin’s diplomatic acumen in Versailles to secure France and Spain’s official recognition of the United States as an independent nation – and with it the gradually increasing military support that would ultimately bring victory.

George Goodwin is the author of Propaganda Wars of the American Revolution: From the Boston Patriots to George Washington (Yale University Press, 2026)

Ad

This article was first published in the July 2026 issue of HistoryExtra Magazine

Ad

Ad

Loading...

Ad

Loading...