Is East of Eden based on a true story? Inside the new Netflix adaptation of John Steinbeck’s novel

East of Eden tells the story of two families, the Trasks and Hamiltons, and traces the impact of “psychic monster” Cathy Ames on their lives. But how true is the new Netflix series to Steinbeck’s epic tale – and California in the 19th and 20th centuries? Jonathan Wright investigates

Florence Pugh and Christopher Abbott in period clothing walk past a horse-drawn cart outdoors. She wears a blue plaid fitted suit with a rolled hat and holds a handbag, while he walks alongside carrying a carpet bag.

Published: October 1, 2026 at 7:30 PM

Save

Published in 1952, John Steinbeck regarded East of Eden as his greatest novel. “It has everything in it I have been able to learn about my art or craft or profession in all these years,” he later said. Primarily set in the Salinas Valley in California, it follows the story of two families: the Trasks and the Hamiltons. Steinbeck took the title of the book from the Book of Genesis. He explores the novel’s themes – love, depravity, moral courage, the way our lives are shaped by those who go before and the choices we make – with reference to the story of Cain and Abel, the sons of Adam and Eve.

Ad

Playing out over seven episodes, the Netflix version of East of Eden has space to explore these weighty themes. Adapted for the screen by Zoe Kazan, the mini-series stars Florence Pugh in the key role of Cathy. Ciarán Hinds stars as expansive Irishman Samuel Hamilton, a figure based on Steinbeck’s own maternal grandfather.

Is the new version of East of Eden faithful to John Steinbeck’s novel?

Far more faithful than the 1955 movie version. Directed by Zoe Kazan’s paternal grandfather, the Academy Award winner Elia Kazan, and co-starring James Dean, the film focused on the final third of the novel – and even then took some liberties with the plot. In contrast, the new version returns to the idea of the novel being a saga that plays out over three generations. So it is that we first meet the Trasks, Adam (Christopher Abbott) and Charles (Mike Faist) in rural Connecticut in the latter part of the 19th century. As for Cathy, we learn her childhood backstory.

Three people in Victorian-era clothing pose in a formal portrait setting with floral and classical column background; one man seated, one man standing, and a woman in a white dress holding a book

Mike Faist (left), Christopher Abbott and Florence Pugh star as the Trask brothers and Cathy Ames in the new adaptation, which stays largely faithful to the original novel | Credit: COURTESY OF NETFLIX

In an interview about her work on the script, Zoe Kazan highlighted a quote from Steinbeck: “It will actually be two books, the story of my country and the story of me.” This became Kazan’s “credo” in that she wanted her adaptation to be both “epic and intimate” – which the series is, a tale of expansion into the American West that takes in the aftermath of the Civil War, the Indian Wars and the First World War, yet often plays out in spaces that are domestic and, in scenes set in brothels, certainly intimate.

Importantly, there’s arguably more of a focus on Cathy, someone Steinbeck describes as “malformed” and a “psychic monster”, in the series than the book. Some readers have found her to be too unsympathetic, even hard to believe in because her actions are often so extreme. Nevertheless, Kazan says she “carried around and puzzled over” Cathy after first reading East of Eden as a teenager. Her Cathy is “rooted” in the novel, yet she has also noted: “I wanted to make sure that she was a person and not just an archetype, and I think that really required me to do some unfolding rather than inventing.”

A young woman in a blue patterned dress sits pensively in a wicker chair against a worn wooden wall, appearing thoughtful and somber in a rustic, vintage setting.

Florence Pugh in the lead role of “psychic monster” Cathy. For screenwriter Zoe Kazan, it was important to present the character as more than just an archetype | Credit: COURTESY OF NETFLIX

How easy was it for women to make their way in the world independently in the USA in the late 19th and early 20th centuries?

Not easy at all. Though it was being steadily eroded from 1839 onwards, the common law doctrine of coverture still had a significant impact on married women, whose legal identities essentially became subsumed to those of their husbands. Married women couldn’t own property or sign contracts, for example. Any wages they earned belonged to their husbands. Widows and single women, however, retained the right to own property. For some women, this meant owning brothels.

How realistic is the portrayal of sex work in East of Eden?

Mild spoilers ahead, but Cathy, who has many sociopathic traits, is a particularly monstrous brothel madam. Her establishment is notorious for the depravity it allows, and she gathers dark secrets as a way to blackmail the great and the good. Over the top? Perhaps, especially as this was a patriarchal society, but other aspects of Cathy’s behaviour tally with historical records, such as the way she uses drug addiction to control her workers.

In terms of the wider history of sex work in California, this began in earnest during the Gold Rush (which started in 1848–49), when it’s estimated the male-to-female ratio as high 50-1 in some areas. Sadly, many women were trafficked into California. As the state’s economy developed, red light districts were tolerated. In 1872, though, California enacted Penal Code 647, underpinned by a sense of high-minded moral purpose, and which cracked down on such activities as drug use, begging and sex work.

Black-and-white photograph of 19th-century gold miners posed along a wooden sluice box.

A group of miners dig at Auburn Ravine during the California Gold Rush. This time of immense economic growth resulted in many red-light districts cropping up, with sex work and trafficking common in the state | Credit: Getty Images

Steinbeck wrote often about sex workers. His Monterey-set 1954 novel Sweet Thursday, a sequel to Cannery Row (1945), centred on the romance between a marine biologist, Doc (based on Steinbeck’s friend Ed Ricketts) and Suzy, a drifter who works for a time at the Bear Flag Restaurant, a brothel.

Does East of Eden reflect the real-life history of Salinas Valley?

While Salinas Valley is one of California’s richest agricultural regions, known as “America’s salad bowl”, there are areas that would have been tough to cultivate as the land was being settled. Salina, it’s worth noting, is the Spanish term for a salt marsh. This is reflected in East of Eden. While the Trask land is fertile and close to the river, the Hamiltons try to eke out a living on poor soils that lack water. The Trasks, it becomes clear, are richer materially yet the Hamiltons are happier, wealthy in terms of family bonds and friendships.

While the mini-series leans less into Steinbeck’s family history than the novel, he wrote the book in part for his sons, Thom and John. Steinbeck, born in Salinas in 1902, wanted to capture life in the valley for them in an earlier era that, in the wake of the Second World War, was already slipping from memory.

A bearded man in a dimly lit room hugs two young boys close to his chest, providing comfort. All three have serious, emotional expressions, suggesting a moment of sadness or reassurance

In this scene from East of Eden, Adam Trask (Christopher Abbott) hugs his sons, Aron and Cal. For John Steinbeck, the book was a way for him to tell his own sons a story of their homeland from an earlier time | Credit: COURTESY OF NETFLIX

What was life like in California for those with roots in China?

Again, mild spoilers ahead. Adam’s housekeeper Lee (Hoon Lee) is a key character in East of Eden. He’s clever, well read and, on a day-to-day basis, raises the twin boys, Cal and Aron, who Cathy abandons. When speaking to those who don’t know him, Lee speaks pidgin English to avoid attracting attention, a strategy for dealing with the racism of the era that was genuinely adopted by Americans of Chinese heritage.

Lee becomes a close friend to Samuel and the two have long philosophical conversations, notably on the meaning of the Hebrew word timshel, a word God speaks to Cain shortly before Adam’s son commits murder. The duo settle on the translation “thou mayest”, important because it suggests humanity has choice, forced neither to be good nor evil. It’s a definition that helps Steinbeck the novelist tease out what the story of Cain and Abel might be intended to convey.

In the real world, such a friendship would have been highly unusual. Although Chinese immigrants played, for example, a key role in building the US railway system, they faced huge prejudice. In 1882, Congress even passed the Chinese Exclusion Act, which suspended the immigration of Chinese labourers, including those who were skilled. San Francisco’s Chinatown grew to become a city within a city as a safe haven as much as for any positive reasons.

Ad

East of Eden is streaming on Netflix now.

Authors

Jonathan Wright

Ad

Ad

Loading...

Ad

Loading...