Did the ancient Romans of Pompeii know they were destined for doom?

Without modern volcanology, seismic monitoring or any clear understanding of eruption warning signs, the people living in the shadow of Vesuvius in AD 79 had little reason to think that catastrophe was imminent – even if they knew there was something unusual about the landscape around them

Ancient Roman mosaic depicting a tragic theatrical mask with exaggerated features and flowing curls, surrounded by decorative foliage, from the House of the Faun in Pompeii.

Published: June 19, 2026 at 1:06 PM

Save

When Mount Vesuvius erupted in AD 79, burying Pompeii, Herculaneum and surrounding settlements beneath ash, pumice and volcanic debris, many of those caught in the disaster seem to have been taken by surprise – according to the historical record. The people living around Vesuvius had no equivalent of modern seismology, no Richter scale, no concept of tectonic pressure, and no scientific model that could reliably connect earthquakes, gas emissions and subterranean rumblings to an approaching volcanic catastrophe.

Ad

As Dr Jess Venner, ancient historian and archaeologist at the University of Oxford, has argued, the inhabitants of Pompeii did not know they were in immediate and catastrophic danger. They lived in a landscape that could seem strange and unstable, but not one that clearly announced apocalypse.

This does not mean the Romans were oblivious to the peculiarities of the region around Vesuvius. On the contrary, there were clues that the area was unusual.

Speaking on the HistoryExtra podcast, Venner points out that the wider region was associated with the Phlegraean Fields – a name meaning “burning” or “fiery” – suggesting that people retained some memory of volcanic activity in the landscape. Ancient writers also compared the area to Mount Etna in Sicily, long known as a volcano, even though Etna itself had not erupted for centuries.

Writers such as the geographer Strabo described features that, in retrospect, seem suggestive. According to Venner, Strabo refers to rocks around the volcano that looked as though they had been “eaten by fire”. Since Strabo died roughly 30 years before the eruption, such observations indicate that traces of earlier volcanic activity were visible well before AD 79.

There was also a broader sense that the land itself was hollow or unstable. Strabo wrote of the region between Cumae and Sicily as being full of subterranean chambers and passages. In antiquity, people often imagined the earth beneath Campania as riddled with tunnels and cavities.

From such details, Venner suggests, there may have been occasional murmurs of concern. But even if some people suspected the area was strange, that did not mean they understood what danger it posed.

Why people stayed in Pompeii

If Vesuvius had a threatening past, it also offered enormous advantages in the present.

The land around Pompeii was famously fertile. Venner describes it as “verdant”, and Vesuvius itself appears in Roman frescoes covered in vines. The agricultural wealth of Campania was one of the region’s great attractions.

“They would get three to four harvests a year in this area, so there was a very good reason to be there,” Venner says.

The irony, of course, is that this fertility was itself linked to volcanic activity. Over time, volcanic ash enriches soil with nutrients, creating highly productive farmland. In the long term, the volcano helped sustain the prosperity of the communities that lived beside it.

There was also a social divide in who possessed what knowledge. Much of the written discussion of the landscape came from elite authors – geographers, natural philosophers and historians – whose works circulated among educated aristocratic circles rather than the wider population.

Roman Britain | A short course from HistoryExtra Academy

Member exclusive | In this four-week course, discover everything you need to know about Roman Britain, guided by Rob Collins, professor of frontier archaeology at Newcastle University. Explore the course now

“You’ve got to think about who’s reading these things. It’s not the everyday person,” Venner notes.

Even if those clues had been more widely known they would still have been difficult to interpret. Ancient Romans lacked a developed scientific understanding of volcanoes. Strikingly, Pliny the Elder – who wrote the vast Natural History, one of antiquity’s great encyclopaedic works – never explicitly identified Vesuvius as a volcano, despite living close enough to see it regularly.

If even one of the Roman world’s most learned men did not recognise Vesuvius for what it was, it is hardly surprising that ordinary inhabitants of Pompeii did not think they were living beneath a ticking geological time bomb.

A cobbled street in the ruins of Pompeii, lined with roofless buildings and worn stone pavements, with Mount Vesuvius rising in the distance.

A street in Pompeii photographed in 1938, nearly two millennia after the city was destroyed by the eruption of Mount Vesuvius in AD 79. The remarkably preserved roads, buildings and public spaces offer a glimpse into everyday Roman life. (Photo by Getty Images)

The warning signs they could not read

Today, earthquakes, gas emissions and changes in the ground can all be recognised as potential warning signs of volcanic unrest. In Roman Campania, such phenomena were not necessarily alarming.

“Pliny the Younger tells us later on that the people of Campania weren’t concerned because earthquakes were just so common for them,” Venner says.

That is crucial. Earthquakes formed part of the ordinary background of life in the region. Repeated tremors would not automatically have suggested that a major eruption was imminent. What seems extraordinary to us may have seemed familiar to them.

The same was true of toxic gases. Venner points to the poem Etna, attributed in antiquity to Virgil though probably written by an unknown author, which describes the area between Naples and Cumae as a place where sulphur continuously emerged from the soil. But this was not read as a sign of immediate catastrophe.

There had also been a major earthquake some 16 or 17 years before the eruption, usually dated to AD 62 or 63. Ancient writers including Seneca describe widespread destruction.

“Seneca tells us that an earthquake flattened Pompeii, there were great ruins in Herculaneum, and it caused minor damage in Nuceria and Naples,” Venner says. “They also say that a flock of 600 sheep was killed – we think by toxic gases.”

But even this did not prompt mass flight from the area. Instead, people rebuilt. Archaeological evidence suggests that repair work continued right up to the eruption of AD 79. Venner has also noted signs that more wells may have been opened in the aftermath of the earlier quake.

“It’s almost like they were trying to relieve the pressure they think is happening under the earth,” she says, “by letting out the air from underground passages through wells.”

Gods, giants and the subterranean world

Some Roman thinkers, including Seneca the Younger, came surprisingly close to linking earthquakes, hollow ground and volcanic activity together. But such ideas existed alongside (and were often overshadowed by) religious and mythic explanations of the natural world.

One tradition associated volcanic fire with Vulcan, the Roman god of fire and metalworking, whose subterranean forge was thought to lie beneath mountains such as Etna. Another held that volcanoes were connected to imprisoned giants, buried beneath the earth after their defeat by the gods.

The poet Silius Italicus, for example, wrote that the giants crushed beneath the ground shook the earth and scorched the fields with their burning breath as they struggled to escape.

As Venner notes, there were even whispers during the eruption itself that giant figures could be seen in the smoke.

Such stories indicate how people understood dangerous landscapes. Romans didn't divide myth and science as sharply as modern societies do. Natural phenomena were still often interpreted through the actions of gods and legendary beings, rather than through a modern geological model.

Ad

Jess Venner was speaking to Kev Lochun on the HistoryExtra podcast. Listen to the full conversation.

Authors

Serafina KennyFreelance journalist

Serafina Kenny is a freelance journalist specialising in the history of health, relationships, and social culture

Ad

Ad

Loading...

Ad

Loading...